Group
projects to me are never 100% good or 100% bad. It usually is luck of the draw
depending on the group members I am assignment to have. This semester, I
specifically, have an example of a positive experience with a group project
that I am still working in. For a political science course that I am in, we
have a large project that we have been working on for the course of the
semester. Our group is made up of 3 people total and we have had no problems to
date. It worked out that all three of us got along very well and since our
project was stretched out for so long, we have been able to work on every
section of the project together. Every other week we meet up at the UGL for an
hour or two at a convenient time (usually on Sundays) and work on our project together.
Since all three of us are there, there is not a “slacker” in our group and
everyone is happy. I believe that the reason we have been so successful in our
group is because of our similarities in personalities and talent. We all have
the same major, have take similar classes, and have similar interests in our
project. Our group members were chosen based off of who preferred each topic so
I think that was also a big factor in why we were doing so well, because we
were all genuinely interested in our topic.
On the
other hand, there have been many instances in my college career where my group
project was the least desirable experience. During an online class I took last
summer we were assigned a group project where we had to work on a debate
together. This project seemed almost impossible since it was over the summer,
online, and we were never able to physically meet with our group. Even getting ahold
of my group members via email was extremely difficult. The way that we divided
work was I sent an email with the parts of the debate and everyone just chose
one section. We all worked on it separated and had no clue if our members were
putting in the work and effort they should have been putting in before the
debate. There was on group member who never responded to our emails and while we
just assumed he got them, we emailed our professor to check if he dropped the
course and when he said he is still enrolled we assumed that he would do the
work for the debate. As the debate was approaching none of my group members
still received any sort of response from the group member we hadn’t made
contact with all summer so myself and another group member took it on ourselves
to do his work. The day of the debate, that group member that wasn’t responding
all summer never entered the debate so we were very glad we did his work for
him. Although in the end our grade for the debate was great, it was a very
stressful situation. Ten minutes before the debate started was the first time
we were able to share with our group members the research that we did. We fully
trusted one another to do the work and that was a very stressful situation.
This was the worst example of a group project because of the lack of
communication that we were able to have with our group members as well as lack
of consistent effort portrayed from each group member.
I think similarities in personality and talent is definitely something that helps in a group setting. I have personally experienced this from my classes at school. Whenever I have a group project for a class such as a gen ed class there seems to be problems arising because nobody takes the class seriously. Gen ed classes are made up of people from various majors and I have personally seen people slack off because they don't take the class seriously. On the other hand, if I'm in a class that is related to my major then I tend to do better in group projects. Typically the people that I work with are in the same field of study and have similar knowledge in the subject because they are in that particular class with me.
ReplyDeleteI agree that similarities in interests and talent are important in the makeup of a group. I like your point about communication too - groups work best when everyone knows what's going on and that the other people are pulling their weight.
ReplyDelete